Friday, March 2, 2012

Final Reflection

This class wasn't too bad.  Being a required course, I can't say I was very excited to go to class everyday.  But, it wasn't too much of a burden.  I enjoyed when we watched the Zietgiest movie.  I also enjoyed when we did group activities over lecture classes.  When we went outside, it was awesome because I like being outside. 
The final essay wasn't as bad as I thought it would be because we could do it slowly and simply.  I also enjoyed the second essay because we could do it in pieces.  The first was cool too because analyzing images was pretty simple and I could do it on something that I enjoy talking about. 
Overall, this quarter went pretty well, but I am ready to move onto Spring Quarter for something new! 

Presentation Reflection

I was the first person to present my research in the conference presentations in class.  I made a powerpoint and felt very happy with my presentation.  I am good with public speaking, so I wasn't worried about it.  I went through my information as if it was my paper.  I started with "What is Fracking?"  Then, I showed a diagram of how fracking works.  Next, I explained the problem of fracking.  I continued into how it is possible for fracking to go so bad.  Then, I went to Why we do it.  Finally, I finished with my thoughts on the argument, which is fracking could be a very good thing if it is regulated. 

Open Post #3

Deviating from all of this research paper talk, I'm completely switching gears here.
I decided to change my major from Environmental Geography to Restaurant, Hotel, and Tourism with a minor in business and communications.  I am really excited for this change!  I changed it because, while I was very interested in what I was learning in my major classes, but I realized I didn't know what I wanted to do with my life after I graduated.  I didn't really want to actually do what was offered for the rest of my life. 
When I applied to schools, I applied as a marine science major to 7 schools.  One of those was Coastal Carolina.  During my visit, they were pushing a Resort Tourism Management program to us, and I said to myself, If I changed my major if I went there, I would do that.  Learning that OU had a program, I was immediately drawn to it. 
My goal is to work at Disney World.  As crazy as that sounds, I'd love to work at the resorts there.  I'm planning on doing an internship at Disney either my junior or senior year, and hopefully I could get a real job from that. 
This is the most recent change and news in my life, so therefore, it is on my mind a lot.  I feel very content and excited with this change and I"m looking forward to what the future brings!

Piece of my essay: my arguement


After careful consideration and reading numerous articles of both sides of this argument, my own opinion can be summed up in the statement that the Scientific American's Board of Editors said: "Drilling for natural gas has gotten ahead of the science needed to prove it safe."  I feel as if fracking could be a great thing for the United States, and maybe eventually the world, if  certain steps are taken to ensure the safety of the ground water.  In order for the benefits of our economics, clean energy, and clean water from fracking, the government needs to intervene.  First and foremost, the EPA needs to speed up their investigation of the effects of fracking on drinking water.  The government can't step in unless they have valid facts and numbers to deal with.  Once that is done, common standards need to established, such as the max contaminant levels allowed.  The Halliburton Loophole needs to be closed and the FRAC Act passed, so we can know what the chemicals are in the fracking fluid.  We may need to change those chemicals if they prove unsafe.  The technology will improve with time too.  So far, it's been changing to fast to know if it is safe for us to be doing.  They also need to establish common procedures on how equipment is to be made, checked, and double checked.  Leaks due to human error need to be eliminated and monitored.  If the equipment is old, it should be updated.  The government should have to test the water before fracking commences, and then that way if it changes over time, they can figure out what is going wrong and fix it.       

Argument Outline

Question: What are the damaging environmental impacts of fracking and if it causes so much damage, why is it still practiced?
Thesis: Although fracking can cause a lot of water pollution to the drinking water through an exemption of the Halliburton Loophole in the Clean Water Act, fracking can eliminate global warming effects if it becomes regulated to improve the results of the process.
            I. Terry Engelder states that "Fracking is crucial to global economic stability; the    economic benefits outweigh the environmental risks.
                        a. Fracking will provide our needs for enough domestic natural gas for the                                      foreseeable future.  
                        b. Fracking will help alleviate global warming concerns
                        c. There are risks, but they can be managed through new technologies and new                              regulations.
                        d. Fracking is good for national energy security and for global climate because                               burning gas emits less carbon than burning coal. 
            II." Natural gas extracted from shale comes at too great a cost to the environment," says    Robert W. Howarth and Anthony Ingraffea.
                        a.  The chemicals in the Fracking fluid are toxic, carcinogenic, or mutagenic, and                            most alarmingly- secret. 
                        b. Halliburton Loophole needs to be fixed.
                        c. Methane is released and is a greenhouse gas so Fracking really isn't helping the                           global warming concerns.
           

            III.  According to a magazine article from Scientific American, drilling for natural gas has gotten ahead of the science needed to prove it safe. 
                        a.  Unanswered questions on how fracking can contaminate drinking water, the                             extent to which it already has, and what the industry can do to reduce risks.
                        b. Government needs to establish common standards of practices.
                        c. Congress needs to close the Halliburton Loophole.
                        d. Public disclosure of what is in the fracking fluid chemicals.
Conclusion: Fracking can cause the extra fracking fluid to contaminate the drinking water.  On the other hand, it can reduce the amount of global warming gases from getting into the atmosphere.  If proper laws and regulations are put in place to stop the contamination of drinking water, fracking could be very beneficial to not only the United States, but the world.  

Reflection: This research has effectively prepared me for the presentations and it is a good stepping stone for writing my paper!

300 more words of Initial Research

With all these issues and problems, the question of why hydraulic fracturing is allowed to continue is raised. In 1974, the Safe Drinking Water Act was passed by Congress to ensure clean drinking water free from natural and manmade contaminants.  In 2005 in the Bush/Cheney Energy Bill, the Safe Drinking Water Act was amended.  The years before Dick Cheney was vice president, he was a CEO of Halliburton Oil and Gas company.  When he took vice presidency, he formed the Energy Task Force.  This task force only met once with environmental experts before they passed the bill.  In what is now known as the Halliburton Loophole, fracking was exempt from the major federal environmental protection laws.  There was an EPA report called Evaluation of impacts to Underground Sources of Drinking Water by Hydraulic Fracturing of Coalbed Methane Reservoirs.  The author stated that they found that fracking posed "minimal threat" to the drinking water and that "additional or further study was not warranted at that time." The "study" that occurred did not monitor any water wells and just relied on peer reviewed literature and interviews.
             The Halliburton Loophole allows the companies to keep the chemicals in the fracking fluid a secret. In 2009, the Fracturing Responsibility and Awareness of Chemicals (FRAC) Act was introduced to Congress.  The FRAC Act would regulate fracking under the Safe Drinking Water Act and would require the companies to release the  chemicals used in the procedure.  In June of 2011, in response to citizens, politicians, and interest groups, the EPA announced that they were planning to study the impacts of fracking.  According to a United States Environment, Health, and Safety consultant, Rachel Degenhardt,  the study will involve analyzing the full process of hydraulic fracturing from the acquisition of water to the mixing of chemicals, through the ultimate treatment and disposal of produced water.  The sites were identified, prioritized, and selected based off factors such as the site's proximity to human population and the drinking water supplies, evidence of impaired water quality, health and environmental concerns, and unique geological or hydrological features.  This study could potentially be the catalyst for change in the natural gas industry

300 word Initial Research

I watched the movie Gasland and got this research:

In Josh Fox's movie, Gasland, investigates the problems of ground water contamination due to fracking.  While he is not an expert in the field, he interviews the families affected by the contaminations as well as EPA employees.  One clip that resounds with the viewer is the fact that there was so much methane in not only one, but at least four people's, water that he could take a match to it and it would catch on fire.  Fox interviews a chemist named Wilma Subra and she tells a story of her clients being poisoned with arsenic.  She explained that healthy, fit men and women were showing signs of arsenic poisoning.  The doctors would have to ask the spouses of these people to leave the room and ask the patient if there was any possibility that their spouse could be poisoning them.  Subra took samples of water and determined that the arsenic was a result of fracking contamination.  Another interviewee, a man named John Finton describes the toxic vapor that envelopes his house every day.  A cowboy, he worries that not only his family will get sick, but also his animals.  He refuses to move because his ranch has been in his family for years and it is his way of life.  Another women, who wished to remain anonymous in fear of the gas companies coming after her, she showed that when she gets water from her tap, it hisses and bubbles in the cup.  When Cabot Oil and Gas came to investigate and told her the water was fine, she asked them to drink a cup of water in front of her.  Of course, the representatives refused.  She went on to tell that drinking the water made her and her family very sick with troubled stomachs.   Story after story, they all blend together with the fact that animals are dying, the people are getting really sick, and undrinkable water samples.  It's hard not to watch the documentary without getting angry on their behalf.  The government isn't working to solve the problems of the water contamination.  In fact, they are ignoring the issue.