Friday, March 2, 2012

Argument Outline

Question: What are the damaging environmental impacts of fracking and if it causes so much damage, why is it still practiced?
Thesis: Although fracking can cause a lot of water pollution to the drinking water through an exemption of the Halliburton Loophole in the Clean Water Act, fracking can eliminate global warming effects if it becomes regulated to improve the results of the process.
            I. Terry Engelder states that "Fracking is crucial to global economic stability; the    economic benefits outweigh the environmental risks.
                        a. Fracking will provide our needs for enough domestic natural gas for the                                      foreseeable future.  
                        b. Fracking will help alleviate global warming concerns
                        c. There are risks, but they can be managed through new technologies and new                              regulations.
                        d. Fracking is good for national energy security and for global climate because                               burning gas emits less carbon than burning coal. 
            II." Natural gas extracted from shale comes at too great a cost to the environment," says    Robert W. Howarth and Anthony Ingraffea.
                        a.  The chemicals in the Fracking fluid are toxic, carcinogenic, or mutagenic, and                            most alarmingly- secret. 
                        b. Halliburton Loophole needs to be fixed.
                        c. Methane is released and is a greenhouse gas so Fracking really isn't helping the                           global warming concerns.
           

            III.  According to a magazine article from Scientific American, drilling for natural gas has gotten ahead of the science needed to prove it safe. 
                        a.  Unanswered questions on how fracking can contaminate drinking water, the                             extent to which it already has, and what the industry can do to reduce risks.
                        b. Government needs to establish common standards of practices.
                        c. Congress needs to close the Halliburton Loophole.
                        d. Public disclosure of what is in the fracking fluid chemicals.
Conclusion: Fracking can cause the extra fracking fluid to contaminate the drinking water.  On the other hand, it can reduce the amount of global warming gases from getting into the atmosphere.  If proper laws and regulations are put in place to stop the contamination of drinking water, fracking could be very beneficial to not only the United States, but the world.  

Reflection: This research has effectively prepared me for the presentations and it is a good stepping stone for writing my paper!

No comments:

Post a Comment